How to Compare Five-Year EV and Gas Ownership Costs

- PublishedNov 20, 2026
- UpdatedNov 22, 2026
- Sources4
- 11 min read

Compare five years of EV and gas ownership costs with a worked 60,000-mile example covering resale, energy, insurance, interest and charger installation.
Decide First
An electric vehicle may cost less to power and still cost more to own over five years. A gasoline car may have a lower purchase price and still be the expensive choice after insurance, fuel, maintenance and resale are included. The answer depends on the two specific vehicles, the same mileage and a set of realistic assumptions that are visible rather than buried in a sales calculator.
A useful comparison begins with five-year ownership cost, not the monthly loan payment or the price of a tank of gas. Calculate the effective loss in vehicle value, then add the charges needed to finance, insure, maintain and power each car. Include state taxes and fees, tire and repair costs and a home charging installation if needed. Use the same term, coverage, driver profile and expected miles for both vehicles.
For people paying cash, financing interest may be zero but the cost of tying up capital can still be relevant to a personal decision. Don't mix a financing-inclusive model for one vehicle with a cash-only model for the other. This article uses a transparent consumer cash-outlay model for comparability, with the choice of assumptions shown.
Write down these categories for each exact configuration:
Comments are shopper discussion, not verified article evidence.
Comments are not open on AutoUnite yet. Published articles and Ask AutoUnite are the current way to get answers.
AutoUnite content is educational and research-focused. Vehicle information, pricing, ownership costs, maintenance, recalls, and other details may vary by region, dealer, and time.
The basic five-year comparison is purchase price + taxes/fees + financing + insurance + service/repairs/tires + energy + charging setup − resale value. It is deliberately a simplified nominal-dollar model. It doesn't predict inflation, policy changes, investment returns or a guaranteed future resale market.
The FTC recommends requesting the total out-the-door price in writing before negotiating monthly payments. That is an important starting guard against miscounting charges. FTC financing guidance.
Two hypothetical vehicles are the same practical size but have different powertrains. Both are driven 12,000 miles per year. The gasoline car averages 30 MPG and fuel is assumed to cost $3.50 per gallon for the modeled five years. The EV requires 30 billed kWh per 100 miles. In this invented scenario, 80% of energy is purchased at home for $0.15/kWh and 20% at public stations for $0.45/kWh. The energy-weighted average is therefore $0.21/kWh.
Gasoline: 60,000 ÷ 30 MPG = 2,000 gallons. At $3.50, five-year fuel spending is $7,000.
Electricity: 60,000 miles × 30 kWh per 100 miles = 18,000 billed kWh. The assumed blended rate is (0.80 × $0.15) + (0.20 × $0.45) = $0.21. Electricity spending is 18,000 × $0.21 = $3,780. The EV saves $3,220 on modeled energy, but that is not yet the ownership-cost result.
| Five-year item | Gas vehicle | Electric vehicle |
|---|---|---|
| Five-year itemUpfront vehicle price | Gas vehicle$30,000 | Electric vehicle$37,000 |
| Five-year itemExpected resale value | Gas vehicle-$15,000 | Electric vehicle-$18,000 |
| Five-year itemFinancing interest and fees | Gas vehicle$2,200 | Electric vehicle$2,600 |
| Five-year itemTaxes and registration | Gas vehicle$2,300 | Electric vehicle$2,800 |
| Five-year itemInsurance | Gas vehicle$8,500 | Electric vehicle$9,500 |
| Five-year itemMaintenance, tires and repairs | Gas vehicle$4,500 | Electric vehicle$3,500 |
| Five-year itemFive-year energy | Gas vehicle$7,000 | Electric vehicle$3,780 |
| Five-year itemHome charging equipment and installation | Gas vehicle$0 | Electric vehicle$800 |
| Five-year itemModeled ownership cost | Gas vehicle$39,500 | Electric vehicle$41,980 |
The arithmetic makes the tradeoff visible. Despite $3,220 in lower energy costs and a modeled $1,000 service difference, the EV ends $2,480 higher over five years because of the combined effects of purchase, resale, insurance, financing, taxes and charger setup. There are no brand-specific performance claims, quotes or forecasts hidden in these figures. Every dollar is a scenario input that should be replaced before a personal decision.
Imagine the same EV owner lacks convenient home charging. The public share of energy rises from 20% to 60%, while the home rate stays $0.15 and the public rate stays $0.45. The blended rate becomes (0.40 × $0.15) + (0.60 × $0.45) = $0.33 per kWh. Using 18,000 billed kWh, five-year electricity rises to $5,940. That is $2,160 more than the earlier EV energy line, so the same model's EV total becomes $44,140, all else equal.
This illustrates the economics of charging access rather than a claim about current national prices. Peak and off-peak utility tariffs, demand charges, per-minute station billing, membership discounts and charging losses vary. Get the actual utility plan, expected public pricing and any station fees for your area. Use the DOE's guidance to assess equipment and installation rather than assuming every home already has a suitable circuit. DOE home charging.
Home charging can be extremely convenient as well as cheaper under a favorable tariff. But if an apartment, shared lot or parking arrangement prevents installation, the calculation must be redone with the charging access you actually have, not the one a brochure assumes.
Buying price is observable when you have a quote. Five-year residual value is not. Use a range based on comparable used vehicles at the mileage and condition you expect. Pay attention to trim, drivetrain, accident history, geographic demand and the technology or warranty context for that exact model year. Do not assume all EVs depreciate faster or that all gasoline vehicles retain value equally.
Return to the example. If the EV sells for $16,000 rather than $18,000, its modeled cost increases by $2,000 to $43,980. If the gas car's resale estimate is also uncertain, test a downside case for it too. The more a decision depends on one high resale estimate, the less robust it is.
Use a realistic sale price rather than a dealer's advertised retail asking price as though you can realize that amount automatically in a trade-in. If comparing private sale versus trade, model the expected proceeds net of additional transaction effort and fees. Avoid crediting speculative tax benefits without checking local rules and eligibility.
Get quotes for both VINs or the closest insurable specifications. Coverage costs can differ with repairability, parts costs, driver factors, location, claim history, vehicle value and coverage limits. A general internet average cannot substitute for the premium a carrier will quote for your situation. Repeat at renewal, because current quotes are not guaranteed for five years.
For finance, compare the APR, total paid, loan term, fees and payoff balance. If you plan to sell in year five on a six- or seven-year loan, include only the financing cost incurred during ownership and account separately for the remaining payoff. You do not add the outstanding principal again to the purchase price in a depreciation model; the debt balance matters for closing cash, equity and the timing of payments. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau explains why comparing financing offers requires more than monthly payment size.
Check maintenance schedules and vehicle-specific coverage instead of applying a universal “EVs need no maintenance” claim. EVs still use tires, suspension components, brakes, filters and other consumables, while gas vehicles require engine-related service. Both can incur expensive repairs outside warranty. For hybrids and plug-in hybrids, use a separate worksheet rather than forcing their ownership profile into a fully electric or gasoline category.
Do not insert an assumed federal, state or utility incentive unless the exact transaction date, vehicle, applicant and program qualify. Eligibility and availability can change. A tax credit that a buyer does not qualify for is not a valid reduction in total cost. Dealer discounts, manufacturer incentives and tax treatment also operate differently. Record each separately and make sure it is reflected exactly once.
The same caution applies to projected future fuel prices. This example uses static prices solely to demonstrate the calculation. A rigorous purchase decision should test a lower and higher fuel scenario, different annual mileage and the buyer's actual electricity plan. If you will drive only 5,000 miles a year, energy savings may matter less relative to insurance and depreciation than they do for a high-mileage commuter.
Scenario 1: Mostly home charging. Use your actual off-peak or standard rate, expected charging losses and installation cost. This is not the same calculation as station-only charging.
Scenario 2: Mostly public charging. Use the actual networks you can access. Include higher rates, extra travel to charge and fees when material. Don't invent free electricity to make the EV column attractive.
Scenario 3: Conservative resale. Reduce the expected resale proceeds for both vehicles to test whether the decision reverses.
Scenario 4: Higher maintenance or insurance. Reprice the exact insurance quotes and add a plausible repair reserve. The direction of cost difference may change with a single expensive assumption.
For each scenario, show the new cost difference and identify what input would have to change for the other powertrain to become less expensive. This turns an opinion into a decision threshold you can revisit when quotes arrive.
Not necessarily. Electricity prices, vehicle consumption, driving conditions and public charging fees matter. Compare billed energy per 100 miles with gas gallons per 100 miles for your exact vehicles and rates.
No. A lower monthly payment can come from a longer loan and higher total interest. Use the purchase and finance schedules together. Monthly cash flow remains important, but it measures a different constraint.
In this simplified ownership model, purchase price minus resale value captures vehicle value lost; financing interest and fees are additional. Adding all principal payments on top double counts the purchase cost. Use a separate cash-flow schedule when timing or negative equity matters.
Include it if you will pay for it and cannot reliably recover the expenditure. If you have an existing suitable setup, record the actual incremental cost, which may be zero. Consider any reimbursement or transfer assumptions only if documented.
You need a reasonable planning range based on current comparable quotes, not a false promise of future premiums. Re-run the analysis when rates change.
Collect both written out-the-door prices using the OTD price checklist, request insurance estimates, use the correct fuel-economy label and calculate a plausible resale range. If the issue is specifically the public-charger break-even point, use the EV-versus-gas cost-per-mile calculator explainer.
Method disclosure: All sample vehicle prices, resale values, insurance, rates and costs are illustrative, not live market data. Five-year totals and scenario adjustments independently recalculated from the stated inputs. Incentives and location-specific taxes are excluded unless explicitly modeled.